Losing a tooth used to earn you a quarter—maybe a dollar if you were lucky. But kids today are waking up to a lot more under their pillows. So what gives? Has the Tooth Fairy gotten a raise? Are baby teeth booming in value?
As a dentist in Idaho Falls, we see lots of little patients eagerly awaiting their first lost tooth—and parents who are unsure what the going rate is these days. Let’s dive into the delightful and slightly bizarre world of the Tooth Fairy economy.
The Going Rate for a Tooth
According to a 2025 survey by Delta Dental, the national average payout for a baby tooth is now around $6.23. That’s more than double what it was a decade ago and over 24 times what it was in the 1950s (about 25 cents).
Rates vary by region and even tooth type. Some kids get a bonus for their first tooth, and others get more for molars. Here’s what the Tooth Fairy might be leaving these days:
- First tooth: $7–10
- Front tooth: $5–6
- Molars: $4–5
- “Inflation bonus” night (Tooth Fairy forgets and comes late): up to $20!
Why the Rise in Tooth Value?
Tooth Fairy generosity seems to reflect more than just childhood milestones. Experts suggest the increase is tied to:
- Inflation: As the cost of living rises, so do Tooth Fairy contributions.
- Parental Guilt: Busy schedules and missed bedtime routines may inspire parents to “make it up” with extra generosity.
- Social Media Pressure: When one parent posts about a $20 payout, others feel pressure to match it.
- Fun Factor: Some parents use the opportunity to create fun traditions—glitter trails, special notes, or even tiny fairy doors.
What Does the Tooth Fairy Teach Us?
While the economics are amusing, the Tooth Fairy also helps kids learn important lessons about oral hygiene and growing up:
- Milestones Matter: Losing teeth is a rite of passage that celebrates healthy growth.
- Hygiene Has Rewards: The idea of being “Tooth Fairy ready” can encourage kids to brush and floss regularly.
- Managing Money: If your child receives real currency, it’s a great chance to introduce saving and budgeting.
How to Celebrate Tooth Loss (Without Breaking the Bank)
You don’t need to take out a second mortgage to celebrate a lost tooth. Here are some fun, affordable ideas:
- Leave a shiny $1 coin or foreign currency.
- Write a tiny note in fairy handwriting.
- Use glitter or a “fairy receipt.”
- Offer a new toothbrush as a bonus gift.
- Start a tooth loss chart to track milestones.
What If a Tooth Is Lost Prematurely?
Sometimes kids lose a tooth too early due to an accident or decay. In these cases, your Idaho Falls dentist may recommend a space maintainer or exam to ensure the adult teeth have room to grow in properly.
If your child loses a tooth unexpectedly or shows signs of dental trauma (bleeding, pain, or discoloration), it’s always a good idea to give your dentist a call.
The Takeaway
The Tooth Fairy may be whimsical, but she also plays a surprisingly big role in modern family life—and kids’ financial literacy! Whether your household sticks with a classic dollar or embraces a higher-value fairy payout, the most important thing is to make it magical and meaningful.
And remember: behind every healthy baby tooth is good brushing, routine checkups, and a kid who’s growing up fast. When those new adult teeth arrive, we’re here to help keep them strong, straight, and sparkly.
If you’ve got questions about your child’s dental development—or just want to make sure the Tooth Fairy has a reason to visit—your trusted Idaho Falls dentist is here for the whole family.
